India

Supreme Court Upholds Maintainability Of West Bengal’s Suit Against CBI

The Supreme Court delivered a significant ruling on Wednesday, affirming the maintainability of West Bengal’s suit against the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) over its handling of post-poll violence cases without state consent.

A Bench led by Justice B R Gavai dismissed objections raised by the Union government regarding the suit’s validity under Article 131 of the Constitution.

The Court clarified that its decision on the suit’s maintainability pertained specifically to preliminary objections raised by the Centre and would not influence the suit’s final adjudication.

The matter, which will now proceed to framing of issues on 13 August, follows earlier arguments presented by Solicitor General Tushar Mehta for the Centre and senior advocate Kapil Sibal representing West Bengal.

The state government’s plea argues that the CBI violated provisions of the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946, by conducting investigations and filing FIRs without requisite state consent.

Conversely, the Centre contended that a state cannot issue blanket directives withdrawing consent for CBI probes and must justify such decisions on a case-by-case basis.

The Union’s Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) underscored that consent withdrawal must be based on valid and substantial reasons.

The CBI’s involvement in multiple FIRs related to post-poll violence in West Bengal has been contentious, prompting the state government to seek a stay on these investigations following a Calcutta High Court order.

The Trinamool Congress government had earlier withdrawn general consent granted to the CBI for conducting probes within the state.

The Supreme Court had initially taken up the case in September 2021, issuing notices and subsequently deliberating over the legality and procedural aspects of the CBI’s actions vis-à-vis state consent requirements.

Also Read: Nitish Kumar To Inaugurate Expansion Of JP Ganga Pathway In Patna

Gopal Krishna

Recent Posts

Pope Francis Funeral: President Murmu & PM Modi Pay Final Tributes

Pope Francis, the first Latin American pontiff, was laid to rest in a humble ceremony…

58 mins ago

Man Arrested For Raping Six-Year-Old Girl In Bihar’s Vaishali District

The Bihar police have taken swift action in arresting a man accused of raping a…

2 hours ago

PM Modi Distributes Over 51,000 Appointment Letters In 15th Rozgar Mela

PM Modi distributed 51,236 appointment letters to newly-recruited candidates in central government departments and organisations…

4 hours ago

Indian Embassy In Berlin Holds Memorial For Pahalgam Terror Victims

The Indian Embassy in Berlin organised a solemn memorial service to honour the victims of…

5 hours ago

Joe Jonas Reflects On Disconnecting From Technology And Reliving Childhood

Pop star Joe Jonas recently performed his latest single, Heart by Heart, to a phone-free…

5 hours ago

Chennai Super Kings’ Struggles Continue As Sunrisers Hyderabad Secure Crucial Win

CSK captain Mahendra Singh Dhoni has openly acknowledged the team's ongoing struggles in the 2025…

5 hours ago