India

Allahabad High Court Rules Not Every Arrest And Detention Amounts To Custodial Torture

The Allahabad High Court dismissed a plea on Tuesday, emphasizing that not all arrests or detentions equate to custodial torture. The court stated that without clear medical or supporting evidence, allegations of torture should not prompt proceedings. Justices Mahesh Chandra Tripathi and Prashant Kumar highlighted that courts must balance the protection of fundamental rights with the prevention of false claims that could disrupt policing.

Shah Faisal, the petitioner from Maharajganj, alleged that police officers detained and beat him in February 2021 over a bribe demand of Rs 50,000. He claimed his attempts to file an FIR were ignored by local police. However, state officials argued the allegations were unsubstantiated.

Criteria for Custodial Torture Claims

The court outlined essential criteria to consider before awarding compensation, including (a) evidence of human rights violations, (b) the gravity of alleged abuse, and (c) proof of harm to the individual’s rights. It stressed that awarding compensation without concrete proof could open the floodgates for baseless petitions, complicating investigations and leading to financial demands on the state.

Court Finds No Grounds for Compensation

Dismissing Faisal’s petition, the court noted that an independent investigation found no evidence against the officers. It underscored that mere allegations, without medical corroboration or witness testimony, do not justify claims of torture. Additionally, the court urged that those with regular criminal records cannot misuse compensation claims without firm evidence.

Also Read: PM Modi Criticizes Congress For ‘Unfulfilled Promises’ And Declining Fiscal Health In Party-Ruled States

Vishal Talwar

Recent Posts

PM Modi Engages In 31 Bilateral Meetings During Three-Nation Tour

PM Narendra Modi held 31 bilateral meetings and discussions during his visit to Nigeria, Brazil,…

24 minutes ago

SC Reserves Verdict On Challenge To ‘Socialist’ And ‘Secular’ In Preamble

These words were added during the 42nd Amendment in 1976, under the tenure of Prime…

32 minutes ago

CPS Appointment Cancellation: Supreme Court Issues Notice to Himachal Pradesh Government

During the hearing, the Supreme Court clarified that the six MLAs removed as Chief Parliamentary…

49 minutes ago

BGT 2024-25: India 150 All Out, Bumrah’s 4-17 Rocks Australia To 67/7 On Day One

Bumrah’s 4-17, backed by Mohammed Siraj and debutant Harshit Rana, helped India seize the momentum…

1 hour ago

Supreme Court Seeks Gyanvapi Masjid Committee’s Response On ASI Survey Request

The SC directed the Gyanvapi Masjid Committee to respond to a plea for an ASI…

1 hour ago

Supreme Court Extends Relief To Udhayanidhi Stalin In Sanatan Dharma Remarks Case

The court extended his exemption from appearing in lower courts until February and granted four…

1 hour ago