India

SC Rebukes DMK Leader Udayanidhi Stalin for ‘Sanatana Dharma’ Remark, Considers it Abuse of Right to Free Speech

The Supreme Court on Monday rebuked Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK) leader Udayanidhi Stalin for his remarks in September suggesting the eradication of “Sanatana Dharma,” emphasizing that such comments abuse the right to free speech. The court reminded Stalin, who is also a Tamil Nadu minister, of the responsibility that comes with his position. 

“You are not a layman. You are a minister…should have realised the consequences of your remarks,” said a bench of justices Sanjiv Khanna and Dipankar Datta while hearing Stalin’s petition for clubbing criminal cases registered against him over the remarks in six states.

Representing Stalin, senior advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi argued that the remarks were made in a closed-door meeting, not in a public setting. He expressed concerns about the persecution his client faced, as cases were filed against him in multiple states, including Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Karnataka, Jammu and Kashmir, and Mumbai.

Also read: Delhi’s Bold Move: Kejriwal Government Unveils ₹1,000 Cash Promise for Women Over 18 in 2024 Budget

However, the court stressed that Article 32, which allows individuals to move the Supreme Court for the enforcement of fundamental rights, cannot be used as a remedy after abusing fundamental rights under Article 19(1)(a) for free speech and expression, and Article 25 for freedom of religion.

“You abuse your Article 19(1)(a)…Article 25… Now you want to exercise your Article 32…Do you know the consequences of what you said,” the bench said.

The court initially suggested approaching individual high courts for the cases, considering the inconvenience witnesses would face traveling across states. Singhvi referenced similar situations faced by journalists and political figures, where cases were clubbed together, citing precedents involving Arnab Goswami, Amish Devgan, Nupur Sharma, and Mohammad Zubair. The court agreed to review these judgments and the proceedings in each case against Stalin before the next hearing on March 15.

Two petitions seeking Stalin’s criminal prosecution for his remarks are still pending before the Supreme Court.

Srushti Sharma

Recent Posts

Adani Group Stocks Recover As Sensex nd Nifty Post Gains

After a major sell-off earlier in the week, Adani Group stocks, led by Ambuja Cements…

8 minutes ago

Sensex Soars 1,961 Points, Nifty Gains 557 In Broad-Based Market Rally

A sharp rally in financial stocks and encouraging US labor market data fueled the uptrend.…

12 minutes ago

PM Modi Engages In 31 Bilateral Meetings During Three-Nation Tour

PM Narendra Modi held 31 bilateral meetings and discussions during his visit to Nigeria, Brazil,…

42 minutes ago

SC Reserves Verdict On Challenge To ‘Socialist’ And ‘Secular’ In Preamble

These words were added during the 42nd Amendment in 1976, under the tenure of Prime…

51 minutes ago

CPS Appointment Cancellation: Supreme Court Issues Notice to Himachal Pradesh Government

During the hearing, the Supreme Court clarified that the six MLAs removed as Chief Parliamentary…

1 hour ago

BGT 2024-25: India 150 All Out, Bumrah’s 4-17 Rocks Australia To 67/7 On Day One

Bumrah’s 4-17, backed by Mohammed Siraj and debutant Harshit Rana, helped India seize the momentum…

1 hour ago