India

Allahabad High Court Acquits Brothers Sentenced to Death in Brutal Murder Case

PRAYAGRAJ: The Allahabad High Court has acquitted two cousin brothers who were sentenced to death in a horrific murder case involving the killing of their mother, sister, and wife by axing them 17 years ago and subsequently shooting them. This verdict was delivered by the division bench comprising Justice Siddharth Verma and Justice Anish Kumar Gupta. Mohd. Shakeel and Mohd. Kaleem had appealed against the death sentence and a fine of Rs 60,000 imposed by the Special Judge of Farrukhabad EC Act Court.

According to the prosecution, Shakeel, a resident of Mohalla Khatakpura, filed a report at Kotwali police station in Farrukhabad on July 26, 2007. The report stated that his relative Mohammad Kalim resided in Mohalla Chhawni Phatak, where his wife Yasmin, mother Noor Jahan, and sister Nasreen lived. All three were attacked with a sharp weapon while asleep at night and subsequently shot. Kaleem, the brother, was also severely injured during the incident.

Subsequently, Inspector Ashok Kumar Shukla, the investigating officer, charged Mohd. Kaleem and Mohd. Shakeel with murder. A charge sheet was filed against them and Lallan alias Lalla, a resident of neighbouring Mohalla Chobdaran.

Following a trial spanning nearly 15 years, Special Judge of EC Act Court Rakesh Kumar Singh found both brothers guilty on October 13, 2022, sentenced them to death, and imposed a fine of Rs 60,000. However, the third accused, Lallan alias Lalla, was acquitted due to insufficient evidence.

After considering the reference sent from the district court to confirm the death sentence and the appeal filed by both convicts, the division bench of the Allahabad High Court acquitted them. In its 31-page judgment, the court also criticized the police investigation and prosecution, stating that the arrests were made based on confessional statements, but failed to ascertain the motive behind the murders. Furthermore, the prosecution could not establish guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

The court emphasized that mere confessions and recoveries are insufficient grounds for conviction. Establishing intent to commit a crime is essential for conviction, a requirement that the prosecution failed to meet.

Also Read: PM Modi Meets Bill Gates To Discuss India’s Digital Revolution; Latter Praises India As ‘Digital Government’

Vishal Talwar

Recent Posts

US, UK Surpass Gulf Nations In Remittances To India In 2023-24: RBI

India’s international migrant stock rose from 6.6 million in 1990 to 18.5 million in 2024.…

7 mins ago

PM Modi’s Humanitarian Gesture In 2016 Continues To Save Lives In Sri Lanka

Sri Lanka's national ambulance service, initiated with 88 ambulances gifted by India in a goodwill…

34 mins ago

GeM Shines At Startup Maha Kumbh 2025; Drives Startup-Government Synergy

At the Startup Maha Kumbh 2025 held in New Delhi, the Government e-Marketplace (GeM) stood…

1 hour ago

India Receives Relief Amid Global US Tariff Hikes, Says NSE CEO

Despite the recent rise in global tariffs, India has received some relief compared to other…

1 hour ago

India’s Foreign Exchange Reserves See Significant Increase; Marking Highest Gain In Five Months

India's foreign exchange reserves continued their upward momentum, rising by USD 6.596 billion to reach…

1 hour ago

Jodhpur High Court To Decide On Asaram’s Interim Bail Extension

The Rajasthan High Court will hear self-styled godman Asaram’s plea seeking an extension of his…

1 hour ago