Analysis

India-Canada Conflict: Canada obfuscates doctrine of Persona-Non-Grata

The expressions of psychological state of Canadian mind in respect of its allegations on India sounds a little too much confused. The question is who actually has violated the provisions of Vienna Convention on diplomatic Relations 1961 & thereby violated International Law?

On 19th October 2023, the Canadian accusation surfaced following India’s askance of Canada to withdraw more than three dozens of its diplomats from India.

Melanie Joly, Canadian Foreign Minister, accuses New Delhi for violating Vienna convention saying, ‘A unilateral revocation of diplomatic privileges and immunities do not support International Law, including the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations 1961.’

Her remarks were followed up by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau accusing India of violating fundamental principals of diplomacy.

Factually and unfortunately for Canada, they cannot blame India for violation of International Law in terms of violation of Vienna convention on diplomatic relations 1961. Obviously the reason is crystal clear. The concept of Persona-non-Grata clarifies it clearly.

The Section 4 of Diplomatic Relations (Vienna Convention) Act 1972 should also be confirmed at this juncture.  Therefore, the allegation is clearly obfuscation of the doctrine of Persona-Non-Grata.

Foreign policy & diplomacy of India has always been conforming to International Law since it’s the International Law only, which grants Immunity & Privileges to Foreign Diplomats. In fact, it also grants Persona-Non-Grata right to the foreign diplomats.

Talk about Persona-Non-Grata. It means, the receiving state has a right to vat any time without assigning any reason that the head of the diplomatic mission or the staff member/ members are not acceptable.

Acting upon this the sending state has two options – either to recall or to terminate his functions with the mission. Or say, here Persona-Non-Grata is a declaration made by a receiving state which tends the existence of diplomatic mission or term of diplomatic agent for good or temporarily.

This is a right which is granted by Article-9 of Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations 1961. It clearly says, the receiving state has a right to notify the sending state without having to explain its decision at any time, that the head of the diplomatic mission or its member/s are  persona-non-Grata, thus are not acceptable.

In such a situation the sending state may, as appropriate, either terminate the person concerned or recall from the mission. That person is thus declared Persona-Non-Grata or not acceptable  even before arriving in the territory of the receiving state.

In accordance with the Article-9, if the sending state fails or refuses within a reasonable time period for carrying out its obligations as per the paragraph 1 of this Article, the receiving state might refuse as well to recognize the person concerned as a member of the mission.

Parijat Tripathi

Recent Posts

Allahabad High Court Slams UP Officials For Defying Judicial Orders

The Allahabad High Court strongly rebuked three senior officials from Baghpat district, the Collector, SDM…

22 mins ago

Adani Group Becomes India’s Fastest-Growing Brand, Driven By Green Energy Focus

The Adani Group has emerged as India’s fastest-growing brand in 2025, registering a massive 82%…

1 hour ago

Pakistan: Flash Floods In Swat Sweep Away 18 Tourists; Claim Seven Lives

Flash floods struck Fizagat, Swat district, on Friday morning, sweeping 18 tourists, including women and…

3 hours ago

105 Electric Buses Flagged Off From DTC: BJP MP Yogesh Chandolia

BJP MP Yogesh Chandolia stated on June 27 that the Delhi government developed 105 electric…

3 hours ago

Alia Bhatt Writes Heartfelt Note For Rekha, Calls Her ‘ReMaa’

Alia Bhatt graced the screening of ‘Umrao Jaan’ in a pink saree effortlessly re-creating Rekha’s…

4 hours ago

Nationwide Mediation Campaign To Tackle India’s Pending Court Cases From July 1

The National Legal Services Authority (NALSA) and the Supreme Court Mediation and Conciliation Project Committee…

4 hours ago