During the hearing of a petition linked to the TN Godavarman case, Chief Justice BR Gavai made powerful observations against the use of hand-pulled rickshaws in the eco-sensitive hill station of Matheran.
He labelled the practice as ‘inhuman’ and said no person would pull a rickshaw by choice, but rather out of necessity due to lack of alternatives.
CJI Gavai emphasised that such degrading practices deeply erode the constitutional ideals of social and economic justice.
“This tradition diminishes human dignity and violates the promises made by the Constitution to every citizen,” he remarked.
Heading a three-judge bench, the CJI expressed concern that, even 45 years after the Supreme Court ruled in favour of independent rickshaw pullers, the practice continues in Matheran.
He termed this a betrayal of the constitutional promise of equality and justice.
“Seventy-eight years after Independence and seventy-five years since the Constitution came into force, allowing one human being to pull another is a national disgrace,” he added.
CJI Gavai urged the immediate abolition of the practice.
While acknowledging concerns about the livelihoods of those affected, he cited a viable solution proposed back in 1980: introducing alternative, eco-friendly options.
He highlighted that technological advancements now allow for sustainable solutions such as e-rickshaws, which can preserve both livelihoods and human dignity.
The Court questioned the efficacy of the Maharashtra government’s response and criticised the lack of urgency.
“Your officers may be under pressure, but we are not,” the CJI asserted, signalling that the judiciary would remain independent and uncompromising on matters of dignity and justice.
Given that Matheran prohibits motor vehicles, the hand-pulled rickshaw has remained a default mode of transport.
The bench, however, rejected this as justification for continuing the exploitative tradition and urged the state to provide alternative employment for the affected workers.
As a progressive alternative, the CJI recommended that Maharashtra study Gujarat’s Kevadia model, where tribal women operate e-rickshaws daily.
This approach preserves employment while offering dignity and economic independence.
The Supreme Court’s intervention marks a pivotal moment in India’s commitment to human dignity and labour justice.
By promoting environmentally friendly alternatives and demanding systemic reform, the Court pushes for a humane and sustainable path forward.
Also Read: Supreme Court Approves Power Tariff Hike In Delhi
Colonel Mustafa urges youth to use geography actively for disaster management, policy, and national development.
India names a record 111-member team for Deaflympics 2025, competing across 11 sports disciplines.
PM Modi, Amit Shah, and leaders extend birthday wishes to Bharat Ratna LK Advani.
Justice Vikram Nath praised PM Modi’s vision for inclusive, tech-driven justice and legal empowerment.
Justice Surya Kant urged empathetic, tech-driven legal aid reforms to make justice accessible and inclusive.
Supreme Court to live stream NALSA’s National Conference and Legal Services Day celebrations online.