India

SC criticizes Army for refusing to promote any woman officers of PC

New Delhi: The Indian Army was chastised by the Supreme Court (SC) for allegedly doing women permanent commission officers “disservice” when they were refused promotion to colonels. The court ruled that the deadline for considering the officers’ confidential reports was “arbitrary” and ordered a new exercise to be carried out in a fortnight to reevaluate the cases of nearly 136 women officers who were competing for promotions.

SC asks for justice to women officers in Army

A bench headed by Chief Justice of India (CJI) Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud said, “The cut off was applied arbitrarily in the present case to ostensibly equate the women officers to their male counterparts.” The Army and the Union government used its policy framework and the March 2021 ruling of the Supreme Court, which established uniform standards for men and women short service commission officers to be considered for permanent commission, to defend their actions.

The bench, also comprising justices JB Pardiwala and Manoj Misra said, “An attitude has been to find some way to defeat the just entitlements of women officers. Such an approach does disservice to the need to provide justice to the women officers, who have already fought a long and hard battle, to get their just entitlements under law.”

Also Read: ED alleges Mahadev app Promoters gave Rs 508 crore to Chhattisgarh CM

Only 108 women officers promoted

The women officers complained in their application filed the previous year that the Special Selection Board – 3 (SB-3) that appoints officers as Colonels had not convened for eighteen months, despite the ruling in Nitisha v. Union of India on March 25, 2021, which directed the Army to provide all consequential benefits, such as financial benefits and promotions, to the women officers within three months. They claimed discrimination because the SB-3 was exclusively for male cops, and officers who were far less experienced than the female officers were being appointed.

Only 108 women officers were promoted out of 150 open positions in SB-3’s declassified results, which were announced in January of this year. There were 136 female officers that were excluded. The Supreme Court was approached by nearly forty female officers protesting their non-empanelment.

42 spots remaining unfilled

Speaking on behalf of the Union government, Attorney General R Venkataramani stated that the deadline of May 31, 2012, was used to determine if the secret reports of female police were equivalent to those of their male counterparts. He went on to defend it by stating that 42 spots remained unfilled and that 108 women officers who met this threshold would be appointed as permanent commission officers in succeeding batches.

The Court said, “In our view, the manner in which the cut off has been applied for reckoning the confidential reports of women officers for empanelment as Colonel is arbitrary as its contrary to the principles laid down in Nitisha judgment and the policy framework enunciated by the Army.” It was further decided that this kind of procedure violated Article 14 of the Indian Constitution, which establishes the fundamental principle of justice.

Srishti Verma

Recent Posts

MyGov Launches Exciting Contests To Celebrate 11 Years Of Transformative Governance

Marking 11 years of transformative governance, citizen engagement platform MyGov has launched a series of…

9 mins ago

President Murmu And PM Modi Extend Eid Al-Adha Wishes, Call For Unity And Service

On Saturday, President Droupadi Murmu and PM Modi extended warm wishes to citizens on occasion…

49 mins ago

JD Vance Resignation Claim Is False; Confirms No Credible Source

Viral claims about US Vice President JD Vance resigning due to tensions between Donald Trump…

1 hour ago

Vikrant Massey Shares Adorable ‘Monkey Business’ Moment With Son In Naples

Actor Vikrant Massey, currently enjoying a family holiday in Naples, Italy, delighted fans by sharing…

2 hours ago

Trending: Eid Al-Adha 2025: The Festival Of Sacrifice Brings Communities Together

Eid al-Adha, also known as Bakri Eid or the festival of sacrifice, stands as one…

2 hours ago

Overcoming Procrastination: Strategies That Help

Discover practical strategies to overcome procrastination, improve focus, and build habits that drive consistent productivity.

3 hours ago