A month after the Supreme Court set timelines for the President and Governors to act on state Bills, President Droupadi Murmu has approached the top court for clarity. President Murmu invoked Article 143 of the Constitution, seeking its opinion on whether courts can impose deadlines on Governors for clearing Bills.
Under Article 143, the President may consult the Supreme Court on legal or public importance matters. Murmu questioned whether a Governor must act on the advice of the Council of Ministers under Article 200. She also asked if a Governor’s discretion is justiciable, citing Article 361, which grants immunity to the President and Governors from court proceedings over their official actions.
The President further asked whether, in the absence of a specific timeline, the court can prescribe deadlines or a manner of exercising discretion under Article 201 of the Constitution.
In April, Justices JB Pardiwala and R Mahadevan resolved a standoff between Tamil Nadu’s DMK government and Governor RN Ravi. The bench called the Governor’s refusal to clear 10 Bills “illegal and arbitrary” and gave a three-month deadline for action on re-passed Bills.
The ruling stated that the President should consult the court on constitutional matters. It noted that while courts avoid political issues, they may intervene when a Bill threatens democratic principles or raises constitutional doubts.
The court clarified that only constitutional courts can assess a Bill’s legality. The Union executive should not judge a Bill’s constitutionality and should refer legal doubts to the court under Article 143.
The court acknowledged its advisory opinions are non-binding. However, it said these opinions carry weight unless outweighed by policy grounds. If the President withholds assent against court advice, the decision must be backed by strong reasons.
The Supreme Court will now decide whether to form a Constitution bench or stand by the earlier two-judge ruling. This development comes as Chief Justice BR Gavai assumes office.
Also Read: Trump Says India Is Offering Us A Zero Tariff Trade Deal
NASA’s Voyager 1 spacecraft, launched in 1977 for a mission lasting just four to five…
Muslims are projected to become the world’s largest religious group by 2035, with population growth…
Prime Minister Narendra Modi met Prince William and Princess Kate in New Delhi, discussed strengthening…
Prime Minister Narendra Modi attended the redevelopment launch of Gurdwara Khalsa Diwan in Manila during…
Vedanta Chairman Anil Agarwal joined Chhath Puja celebrations in London, where hundreds of devotees observed…
Keralam Chief Minister VD Satheesan met Prime Minister Modi in New Delhi, marking a meeting…