Legal

SC Declines Petition Against Rs 3,500 All India Bar Examination Fee; Suggests BCI Representation

On Monday, the Supreme Court refused to entertain a petition challenging the Rs 3,500 examination fee for the All India Bar Examination (AIBE).

A Bench comprised Justice JB Pardiwala and Justice R Mahadevan. They noted that the Supreme Court had already set limits on enrolment fees. These fees are charged by State Bar Councils and the Bar Council of India (BCI).

The judges cautioned that imposing further restrictions could hinder the functioning of bar bodies.

The Court remarked, “You want the bar councils to survive or not. We have already chopped off the upper and lower limbs. They also have staff to pay. Once you pay Rs 3,500 you will start earning Rs 3,50,000 also.”

This reference was linked to the Supreme Court’s July 2024 ruling in Gaurav Kumar v Union of India, which held that enrolment fees charged by State Bar Councils and the BCI cannot exceed limits set under the Advocates Act.

Following this, the Court allowed petitioner Sanyam Gandhi to withdraw his plea and submit a representation to the BCI.

It also granted him the liberty to approach the Court again if the BCI rejects his request.

“We are of the view that the petitioner should highlight to the BCI that this charge is contrary to judgment rendered by this court. Petitioner can file a representation in this regard and wait for a response within reasonable time. He may approach this court and even if there is a negative reply by BCI,” the court noted.

Gandhi had argued that the Rs 3,500 AIBE fee violated Articles 14 and 19 of the Constitution and was inconsistent with the Advocates Act.

He also contended that it was in contravention of the Supreme Court’s 2024 verdict in Gaurav Kumar.

However, the Court did not find merit in his arguments at this stage. It also questioned why the petitioner had not approached the High Court first.

When Gandhi emphasized that the issue concerned the fundamental rights of legal aspirants, the Court reiterated that he should first seek relief from the BCI. If there is no response or an unfavorable reply, he may return to the Supreme Court.

Also Read: SC Declines Plea On Protection Of Hindus In Bangladesh; Cites Foreign Affairs

Gopal Krishna

Recent Posts

Musk-Trump Fallout Threatens NASA And Pentagon Operations: Report

A recent fued between Elon Musk and former US President Donald Trump has raised serious…

32 mins ago

Rajeshwar Singh Honoured With ‘Excellence In Political & Public Life’ Award At House Of Lords

Rajeshwar Singh was honoured with the ‘Excellence in Political and Public Life’ Award at the…

34 mins ago

EaseMyTrip Launches ‘EMT Invest’ To Back Profitable Businesses: CEO Nishant Pitti

India’s leading travel tech company, EaseMyTrip, has launched a new investment platform named ‘EMT Invest’,…

40 mins ago

MyGov Launches Exciting Contests To Celebrate 11 Years Of Transformative Governance

Marking 11 years of transformative governance, citizen engagement platform MyGov has launched a series of…

3 hours ago

President Murmu And PM Modi Extend Eid Al-Adha Wishes, Call For Unity And Service

On Saturday, President Droupadi Murmu and PM Modi extended warm wishes to citizens on occasion…

4 hours ago

JD Vance Resignation Claim Is False; Confirms No Credible Source

Viral claims about US Vice President JD Vance resigning due to tensions between Donald Trump…

4 hours ago