India

Blasphemy: Let Me Speak Review: Kushal Mehra’s Powerful Defence Of Free Speech

Kushal Mehra’s Blasphemy: Let Me Speak confronts the idea of blasphemy head-on, arguing that it is fundamentally alien to India’s indigenous intellectual traditions and that its persistence in law and culture stifles free speech, inquiry, and social progress.

Mehra, host of the popular Cārvāka Podcast and a self-described dharmic sceptic, opens by tracing the etymology and historical evolution of blasphemy. He locates its emergence as a punishable offence primarily within Abrahamic frameworks, where truth is often treated as singular, revealed, and exclusive.

In contrast, Kushal Mehra presents dharmic traditions as rooted in pluralism, debate, and epistemic humility.

Concepts such as anekantavada and the practice of purvapaksha encouraged rigorous argument rather than protecting sacred boundaries through force or law.

Festivals that ritually ‘abuse’ deities and classical texts that celebrate open stages free from prohibition illustrate a culture in which questioning was not merely tolerated but valued.

The book then turns to how this foreign concept entered Indian law.

Kushal Mehra details the colonial-era Rangeela Rasool controversy of the 1920s, which led to the introduction of Section 295A of the Indian Penal Code. He argues that the British institutionalised ‘hurt sentiments’ as a legal category and that independent India’s First Amendment further constitutionalised restrictions on speech that the original framers had not intended.

The result, in Kushal Mehra’s view, is a legal and social environment in which subjective offence can shut down discussion, careers, and even lives.

Critique of Censorship

Particularly striking is Mehra’s critique of what Kushal Mehra terms the ‘Abrahamisation of the Hindu mind’. He warns against Hindus adopting the same dogmatic intolerance they criticise in others, thereby turning a pluralistic tradition into something rigid and exclusivist.

Kushal Mehra dismantles utilitarian justifications for censorship by citing empirical data suggesting that communal violence has declined even as online religious criticism has increased, attributing social peace more to state capacity than to silence. He proposes more speech, not less, as the remedy. He argues that people should expose bad ideas in the open marketplace of argument rather than drive them underground, where they fester.

The final sections highlight the inconsistency of selective outrage.

Kushal Mehra juxtaposes inflammatory passages from various scriptures with the unpunished statements of politicians, contrasting them with the swift consequences ordinary citizens often face for similar expression. He contends that a civilisation that stops questioning eventually stops thinking, and that genuine social reform, from Raja Rammohan Roy to BR Ambedkar, has always required the freedom to challenge orthodoxy.

For anyone concerned with the health of Indian public discourse, this is essential reading.

Vishal Tiwari, Editorial Consultant

With over fifteen years of experience in journalism, I currently serve as Editorial Consultant at Bharat Express News Network. I am also an appointed member of the Hindi Advisory Committee under the Ministry of Home Affairs. Previously, I served as an Assistant Editor at NewsTalk, a monthly magazine focused on tribal issues. In 2014, I became the Delhi representative of an English magazine published from Lucknow, and later joined Rashtriya Sahara in 2016. During the anti-corruption movement led by Anna Hazare, I documented the police action during Baba Ramdev’s protest at Ramlila Maidan through photo reportage. My work also includes publishing a commemorative volume on socialist leader Raj Narain and curating an exhibition of books authored by Members of Parliament that featured works by 132 MPs. Beyond journalism, I am also a Visiting Faculty at the Delhi School of Journalism, where I share my experienc and practical knowledge with aspiring journalists.

Recent Posts

Voyager 1 Is 25.9 Billion Km Away: How Does NASA Still Talk To Its Spacecraft?

How does Voyager 1 keep communicating with Earth from 25.9 billion kilometres away? Discover the…

5 hours ago

Could Muslims Become The World’s Largest Religious Group By 2035? Pew Study Explains

Could Muslims surpass Christians by 2035? Pew Research examines how fertility rates and population growth…

5 hours ago

PM Modi Meets Prince William And Princess Kate In New Delhi

PM Modi meets Prince William and Princess Kate in Delhi to discuss India-UK relations, CETA…

6 hours ago

PM Modi Visits Manila Gurdwara: Why Does Khalsa Diwan Hold Special Significance For Sikhs?

PM Modi attends Gurdwara Khalsa Diwan's redevelopment ceremony in Manila, recognising the Sikh diaspora's heritage.

6 hours ago

‘Jai Chhathi Maiya’ Echoed In London As Anil Agarwal Celebrated Chhath With Indian Diaspora

Vedanta Chairman Anil Agarwal joined Chhath Puja celebrations in London, where hundreds of devotees observed…

7 hours ago

VD Satheesan Meets PM Modi: What Did The Keralam CM Seek From The Centre?

Keralam CM VD Satheesan meets PM Modi in New Delhi, seeking continued Centre support for…

8 hours ago